The Hole Truth

Penny Williams / 16 August 2025

Why the Crumb Matters More Than the Holes.

Camelina Country Sourdough

What we choose to eat and what we choose to wear are more subject to changing fashion than we probably like to think.  Haute cuisine and haute couture both have their loyal cliques, as fast food and disposable fashion have their fans.  Most of us fall somewhere in between. 

I have been a lover of cookery books since my grandmother started collecting the Cordon Bleu magazine series in the mid-1970s.  I've seen fondues come and go and watched quiche be rejected by 'real men' (really).  In the 80s, everything was Cajun, in the 90s it was all sundried tomatoes.  The new millenia arrived on a slice of avocado toast, to be followed by a dizzying whirl of foams, and powdered oddness - squid ink dust, anyone?

Each decade leaves behind a trail of edible icons, and bread has been no exception. In the artisan movement, one feature became a kind of badge of honor: sourdough with cavernous, Instagram-worthy holes. A cross-section full of air pockets was suddenly the ultimate proof of skill and authenticity.

And then, seemingly overnight,  the story of bread got reduced to just that: the holes.  Perhaps it is the sign of an overfed society, but we forgot to celebrate the part we actually eat: the crumb.

The crumb is the soft, structured interior of bread. It is where flavor lives, where nutrition is concentrated, and where texture determines whether a slice delights or disappoints. A good crumb should carry the aroma of fermentation — nutty, tangy, sometimes almost fruity — and distribute that flavor evenly through every bite. Huge holes may look dramatic, but they often mean butter falls through, jam leaks out, and sandwiches collapse. A balanced crumb, gently open but structured, is far more satisfying at the table.

From a nutritional perspective, the crumb does the heavy lifting. Long fermentation breaks down gluten, makes minerals more bioavailable, and encourages gut-friendly lactic acid bacteria. The denser the crumb, the higher the ratio of food to air. Historically, bread was prized as a staple because its crumb offered filling, reliable nourishment — not because it photographed well.

This is especially true for gluten-free sourdough. Without gluten’s stretchy network, the large “artisan holes” are not possible. Yet gluten-free bakers are proving that airy spectacle isn’t necessary for excellence. Instead, we coax flavor from whole grains, develop a moist and tender crumb, and rely on fermentation for digestibility, bioavailability and complexity. The result can be just as rewarding — chewy, aromatic, sustaining — even without the gaping voids.

The crumb, in short, is bread’s soul. It holds the taste, the nutrition, and the substance that make bread worth eating. Holes may be fashionable, but fashion fades. What endures is a loaf whose crumb nourishes both body and spirit — whether it’s wheat sourdough with a gentle open texture, or gluten-free bread that delivers flavor and comfort in every bite.

The loaf in the photos is my Camelina Country Sourdough, as rich, chewy and moist as the best sourdough rye.  I'll be teaching it by request on my Gluten Free Bread Mastery classes. Why not come along?

The Artisan Bakery School
Old Home Cottage
Sparkwell
Devon PL7 5DQ
Email Us