Chimichurri Pulled Bread

Penny Williams / 11 October 2025

Toast, but not as we know it.

Chimichurri Pulled Bread with Fresh Marjoram

This post was intended to be a quiet, autumnal ode to the comforts of toast, in which I am a lifelong believer.  I love everything about it, in all its forms.  From my grandmother's invariably charred offerings, the signature of every holiday breakfast, to the warm, damp, barely coloured slices of 'petrol station bread' that propped up my student hangovers, and onward to the architectural beauties of my husband's artisan sourdough, bronzed to perfection and laquered with organic butter,  toast remains a pillar of my existence.

To do it justice, I consulted Elizabeth David's "English Bread and Yeast Cookery" - a long time personal favourite.  I was sure she would have something pithy to say about toast, but I didn't expect a whole chapter -  the concluding lines of her book, in fact.  You can read it for yourself, but here are a few particularly tasty crumbs.

"All within the sound of Bow Bell are in reproch called cochnies (Cockneys) and eaters of buttered toastes"  (Fynes Morison in 1617)

"It is related of the Duke of Wellington () that when he landed at Dover in 1814, after six years' absence from England, the first order he gave at The Ship Inn was for an unlimited supply of buttered toast."

Following the literary backstory, E.D. offers her readers a few choice recipes. The last but one in the Toast chapter is for 'Pulled Bread'.  This, in the current era of pulled everything from pork to jackfruit, struck me as surprisingly trendy; until I read that the original dates from the 18th century.  

Consisting of morsels of crumb torn from the centre of a freshly baked loaf and 'toasted' in a hot oven until the edges crisp to gold, pulled bread used to be served with cheese.    

I swiftly baked a loaf, and got pulling. (Not a sentence I ever expected to write.)

Recently inspired by a visit to 'Fig' in Split, Croatia, and their toothsome chimichurri potatoes, I decided to serve my pulled bread with  a homemade chimichurri sauce; a modern, Argentinian twist on an historic British dish.  

Make love, as they say, not war.

Bread Recipe

First bake your loaf:

  • Shipton Mill Traditional White Organic Flour 600g
  • 80% very warm water 480g
  • 1% instant yeast 6g
  • 2% salt 12g

Mix to a sloppy dough, temperature about 30 C.  First rise 90 minutes, second rise 30 minutes. Bake at 180 C for 30 minutes.

Freshly baked loaf and chimichurri ingredients

Chimichurri Recipe

Now make your Chimichurri (by hand is best):

  1. Chop  generous handfuls of fresh parsley and coriander.
  2. Mince as many cloves of fresh garlic as you judge decent or wise.
  3. Add shredded leaves of fresh marjoram or oregano to taste (you can sub with dried if necessary).
  4. Add sea salt, black pepper and a teaspoon of chipotle flakes or a fresh, chopped red chilli.
  5. Combine with lots of olive oil and  a light splash of red wine vinegar. Remember, you are aiming for an oil-based condiment, not a puree.
     
Hand chopped herbs, chipotle and garlic

Finally...

While the chimichurri is settling (15 minutes at least), you can slice one long side off your loaf and start pulling out the crumb. (A deliciously atavistic procedure.)

A mixture of different sized chunks is great.  Spread them on a baking sheet and slide them into a hot oven (220 C) for 10 to 15 minutes, until they colour up. 

Anoint your golden chunks of pulled bread with lashings of chimichurri and serve warm. You can add splashes of garlic mayo, or serve this in a dipping bowl on the side.

Chimichurri Pulled Bread is great to hand around with drinks, or cook up a bowl of spicy lentils and it turns into a satisfying supper or lunch.  I hope you try it; I am sure you'll enjoy it.

P.S. The next day, I blitzed the staling crusts into a bag full of breadcrumbs. Waste not, want not :)

All pulled out.
The Artisan Bakery School
Old Home Cottage
Sparkwell
Devon PL7 5DQ
Email Us